Since its introduction to the Premier League in the 2019/20 season, the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) has been one of the most controversial topics in football. Designed to eliminate clear and obvious errors, VAR was supposed to bring fairness and accuracy to decision-making. However, four years later, the debate continues: has VAR improved the game, or has it only created more problems?
The Inconsistency Problem
One of the biggest criticisms of VAR in the Premier League is its inconsistency. While the technology itself is impartial, its implementation and interpretation by referees have led to controversial decisions. Fans often see similar incidents being judged differently from game to game, leaving players, managers, and supporters frustrated.
Offside decisions are a prime example. VAR has ruled out goals for players being offside by the finest of margins—sometimes by a toenail or an armpit. While the rules are technically applied correctly, these marginal calls go against the spirit of the game. Additionally, subjective decisions, such as penalties and red cards, remain a major issue. One week, a handball results in a penalty, while in the next, a near-identical incident is ignored.
Impact on Fans and the Atmosphere
Football thrives on passion and spontaneity, but VAR has significantly impacted the fan experience. Traditionally, goals were celebrated immediately, creating unforgettable moments in stadiums and living rooms alike. Now, fans are hesitant to celebrate until VAR has checked for any possible infringements. This delay can last several minutes, sapping the joy out of the game.
Away from the stadiums, TV viewers are often left confused by the lack of clear communication. Unlike other sports, such as rugby or American football, where referees explain decisions through microphones, Premier League referees do not regularly communicate with fans about why a decision was made. This lack of transparency fuels frustration and conspiracy theories about bias or incompetence.
Has VAR Actually Improved Decision-Making?
While VAR has corrected some major mistakes, its overall impact on fairness is debatable. According to Premier League statistics, the number of correct key match decisions has increased since VAR’s introduction. However, the sheer number of VAR-related controversies suggests that it has not removed controversy—only shifted it to a different area.
Some argue that VAR’s biggest problem is its implementation rather than the concept itself. In leagues like the Bundesliga and Serie A, where referees frequently use pitch-side monitors to review decisions, VAR appears to work more smoothly. In contrast, Premier League referees have historically been reluctant to check monitors, relying instead on officials at the VAR hub. This has led to accusations that referees are no longer making their own decisions, diminishing their authority on the pitch.
READ NEXT: Chelsea Receive Green Light for a £40 Million New Striker Signing